Select Chapter

Between Two Brothers

Chapter 2: Welcome Home

The gate was wrong.

That was the first thing I noticed. Daddy's gate had been weathered cedar with a horseshoe nailed crooked at the top, the same gate I'd swung on as a kid until the hinges groaned. This gate was wrought iron, tall and sleek, with an electronic keypad glowing blue in the dark.

I punched in 4481 with numb fingers. The gate swung open without a sound.

The drive up to the house was different too. The old caliche road that used to rattle my teeth had been paved smooth. New fencing lined both sides, white four-board that glowed like bones in my headlights. The pastures beyond looked lush even in August, which shouldn't have been possible. Daddy had been losing the battle against drought for as long as I could remember.

Someone had poured money into this place. A lot of money.

I crested the hill where the house should've come into view, and my breath caught.

The old Hartley farmhouse was still there, but it was flanked now by a massive new barn, all dark wood and metal roofing. There were new outbuildings I didn't recognize, a covered arena, equipment sheds. Floodlights on motion sensors clicked on as I pulled in, washing everything in harsh white light.

It was Hartley Acres. And it wasn't.

I parked by the old pecan tree, the one thing that hadn't changed, and sat with the engine running. My heart was pounding so hard I could hear it over the AC.

"Mama?" Mason's voice, small and careful. "This doesn't look like a grandpa house."

"It is, baby. It just looks a little different than I remember."

I turned off the engine. The silence of rural Texas settled over us, so thick you could bite it. Crickets. A distant horse nickering. The creak of the old pecan tree swaying.

Then a porch light came on.

A woman stepped out. Mid-fifties, sturdy, with short silver hair and a no-nonsense expression. She wore jeans and a denim shirt and looked at my minivan like she'd been expecting it.

"You must be Ivory." Not a question. She came down the steps with a rancher's walk, steady and sure. "I'm Helen. The house manager."

House manager. Daddy had never had a house manager. Daddy had barely had running water some months.

"I... yes. I'm Ivory. These are my kids." I was unbuckling car seats on autopilot, my hands doing what they always did while my brain spun like a weathervane in a storm.

Helen looked at the triplets and something shifted in her face. Surprise, quickly masked. Her eyes moved from Lily's gray gaze to Mason's quiet face to Noah's sleepy dimple, and I watched her do the math I'd been dreading.

"Well," she said carefully. "Let's get y'all inside."

She carried Noah, who'd fallen back asleep with his thumb in his mouth. I carried Mason on one hip and held Lily's hand, and we walked into the house that used to be mine.

The inside was transformed too. New floors, new kitchen, furniture that cost more than my car. But the bones were the same. The wide hallway. The staircase with the banister I'd slid down as a girl. The window seat where Mama used to read to me before she died.

"Your father's room is down the hall," Helen said quietly. "He's sleeping now. The hospital sent him home with hospice care yesterday."

Yesterday. He'd been home one day, and I was already here. That should've felt good. It didn't.

"I set up the guest room upstairs for you and the children. There are extra blankets in the closet." Helen paused at the kitchen doorway. "There's also a cottage out by the old barn. It's been renovated. More space for the little ones. But tonight, the guest room."

"Thank you." The words came out thick. I was looking at the mantel, where Daddy's old photos still hung. My mother, young and laughing. Me at eight on a horse. And a new photo I'd never seen: two men standing in front of the new barn, hats tipped back, arms crossed, looking at the camera like they owned the world.

Because they did. They owned this world.

My knees went soft.

"Helen." I kept my voice even. Steady Ivory. Always steady. "Who owns this ranch now?"

She looked at me for a long moment. "You don't know?"

"I got a text with the gate code. I didn't ask questions."

"Your father sold Hartley Acres fourteen months ago. The new owners have been renovating since. They kept your father on, let him live here, paid for his medical care."

"That's generous."

"They're good men."

"Who are they?"

Helen folded her hands. She had the careful expression of someone walking through a minefield. "The Montgomery brothers. Caleb and Wyatt."

I'd known. Somewhere in the marrow of my bones, I'd known since that text message. But hearing it out loud was different. Hearing it out loud was a detonation.

The room swayed. I gripped the back of a kitchen chair and breathed through it.

"Mama?" Lily tugged my hand. "You're squeezing too tight."

"Sorry, baby." I loosened my grip. Looked at Helen. "Do they live here?"

"Caleb's in the foreman's house by the east pasture. Wyatt's in the new bunkhouse." A beat. "They know you're coming."

Of course they did. The text. The gate code. They knew.

I put my children to bed in the guest room upstairs, tucking quilts around them, kissing foreheads, whispering lies about how everything was going to be fine. Lily fought sleep the longest, her gray eyes searching my face.

"Mama, why are you sad?"

"I'm not sad, baby. I'm just tired."

"Your eyes are sad."

I kissed her forehead again and sang the lullaby I'd been singing since they were born, an old country song Mama used to sing, until her eyelids grew heavy and closed.

Then I went downstairs, sat on the porch steps of my childhood home, and stared out at a ranch I no longer recognized.

The night was thick with heat and the sound of frogs. Somewhere in the dark, a horse stamped. The pecan tree creaked. And beyond the new barn, a light was on in what Helen had called the bunkhouse.

He was awake. Wyatt was awake, and he knew I was here.

My phone buzzed.

Porch light's on if you need anything. Anytime. - W

I pressed my palms against my eyes until I saw stars. Then I typed back with shaking fingers.

Why do you have my father's ranch?

Three dots appeared. Disappeared. Appeared again.

Then: Come to the main barn at 7am. We'll explain everything.

We.

Both of them.

I turned off my phone, went inside, and locked the door like that could keep out what was coming.

🔥 What happens next?

Continue reading to find out what happens in Chapter 3...